01: Attorney Admissions Anti-ABA Resolution

A RESOLUTION SUPPORTING COMPETITION, PROMOTING THE AVAILABILITY OF AFFORDABLE LEGAL SERVICES, AND OPPOSING DEI REQUIREMENTS IN EDUCATION

WHEREAS, the State of [STATE] supports free markets and opposes monopolization; and

WHEREAS, the Federal Trade Commission has observed that the American Bar Association (ABA) exercises a monopoly on law school accreditation;[1] andWHEREAS, the ABA’s monopoly power is strengthened by State rules that law school graduates can only take a State’s bar exam if they graduated from an ABA-accredited law school; andWHEREAS, the U.S. Department of Education is moving towards removing the ABA’s ability to accredit law schools, based on nearly 30 identified violations;[2] andWHEREAS, State supreme courts in Florida, Texas, Alabama, Tennessee, and Indiana, and a State board of governors under the Washington Supreme Court’s authority, have recently moved away from reliance on the ABA, allowing for increased competition, and other State supreme courts, such as Ohio, are considering similar
actions;[3]–[9] andWHEREAS, the [STATE] Supreme Court currently only allows recent law school graduates to take the bar exam if
they graduated from an ABA-accredited law school [ADJUST AS NEEDED FOR SPECIFIC STATE REQUIREMENT]; andWHEREAS, the ABA’s State-assisted monopoly status has allowed the ABA to impose anticompetitive standards such as limiting online courses, requiring law schools to make costly expenditures not directly related to student achievement, such as having physical library facilities, and requiring a certain percentage of full-time faculty
rather than adjunct or part-time faculty that practice law;[10]–[12] andWHEREAS, the ABA’s overly burdensome standards drive up costs for law schools, create unnecessary barriers to legal educational access, and result in a stagnation of law school innovation; [13] andWHEREAS, these standards restrict the supply of legal services and legal education and increase the cost of both, which benefits attorneys and law professors within the ABA; andWHEREAS, a previous investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division resulted in a ten-year consent decree against the ABA related to alleged anticompetitive conduct that drove up law school costs, as well as a follow-up action in which the ABA admitted it had violated that consent decree; [14]–[15] andWHEREAS, inflation-adjusted in-state tuition at ABA-accredited public law schools was over five times as expensive in 2025 as it was in 1985; [16] andWHEREAS, increased costs create barriers to law school access, discourage the creation of new law schools, restrict law school innovation, and reduce access to legal services; and WHEREAS, the ABA required law schools to provide education to law students on bias, cross-cultural competency, and racism at least twice before graduation; [17] andWHEREAS, the ABA’s monopoly status allowed it to push law schools to provide discriminatory programs to students in order for the law schools to maintain accreditation; andWHEREAS, the ABA also required law schools to demonstrate by concrete action a commitment to diversity and inclusion, including by maintaining a student body and faculty diverse with respect to gender, race, and ethnicity;
[18] andWHEREAS, the U.S. Attorney General has concluded that this ABA requirement violates civil rights laws and conflicts with U.S. Supreme Court guidance, and President Trump has stated in an executive order that this requirement and similar mandates should be eliminated; [19]–[20] andWHEREAS, a U.S. Department of Education report noted that the ABA did not suspend this requirement until long after relevant Supreme Court guidance was issued; [21] andWHEREAS, the ABA House of Delegates rejected an effort to repeal this requirement; [22]
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the [STATE] Legislature calls upon the [STATE] Supreme Court to promote:
  1. Competition among law schools;
  2. Lower-cost and higher-flexibility educational options; and
  3. The widespread availability of affordable and competent legal services.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the [STATE] Supreme Court should remove requirements based on ABA accreditation and permit:
  1. Graduates from [LIST LAW SCHOOLS IN THIS STATE] to sit for the [STATE] bar exam and apply for admission to the [STATE] Bar; and
  2. Graduates from law schools in other States to sit for the [STATE] bar exam and apply for admission to the
    [STATE] Bar, provided they are eligible to sit for the bar exam and seek admission in the state where they graduated.
BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that the [STATE] Supreme Court should explore alternative
requirements that focus on the ability to provide legal services, including:
  1. Allowing participants who complete legal apprenticeship programs to sit for the bar exam;[23]
  2. Approving law schools based on objective standards such as graduates’ bar passage rates, debt-to-income ratios, and employment outcomes; [24]
  3. Working with other State supreme courts to establish accrediting processes focused on the quality of legal education. [25]

References

  1. FTC statement regarding ABA accreditation monopoly.
  2. Department of Education materials regarding ABA accreditation review.
  3. Florida Supreme Court materials.
  4. Texas Supreme Court materials.
  5. Alabama Supreme Court materials.
  6. Tennessee Supreme Court materials.
  7. Indiana Supreme Court materials.
  8. Washington materials.
  9. Ohio proposal materials.
  10. ABA online-learning standards.
  11. ABA law-library requirements.
  12. ABA faculty requirements.
  13. Florida Bar workgroup report.
  14. DOJ antitrust action.
  15. DOJ follow-up action.
  16. LawHub tuition data.
  17. Bias and racism curriculum requirement source.
  18. ABA diversity standard source.
  19. Attorney General statement.
  20. Executive Order source.
  21. Department of Education report.
  22. ABA House of Delegates action.
  23. Apprenticeship proposal source.
  24. Objective accreditation standards source.
  25. Alternative accreditation proposal source.

Latest News >>