The Truth in Proxy Advice Act
Section 1. Legislative Findings
The State of [name of State] finds as follows:
- This State has an interest in accurate representations in proxy advisory services because
of the impact those services have on proxy advisory clients in this State and on companies
headquartered or incorporated in this State. - Proxy advisory services typically are obtained to benefit the economic value of
investments.[1] - Companies that are the subject of proxy advisory services are impacted by proxy advisors,
as major proxy advisors’ recommendations can swing the results of shareholder votes by up
to 30%.[2] - Given the potential impact of these representations, it is essential that proxy advisors
refrain from deceptive or fraudulent representations when providing proxy advisory
services. - States can and should exercise their police power to protect consumers and to prevent
fraud and deceit.[3]
Section 2. Definitions
- (A) “Company”
- Means a business entity whose securities are publicly traded, whether organized as a
for-profit corporation, limited liability company, partnership, or other business entity. - (B) “Default recommendation or policy”
- Means a system, set of rules, principles, or guidelines designed to assist a client with
voting decisions on any proposals. - (C) “Material omission”
Means the omission of a fact that is likely to affect conduct or a decision by a
shareholder acting reasonably in the circumstances with regard to any proposal, including,
but not limited to:- Any information regarding an interest, transaction, commitment, or relationship of the
proxy advisor (or its affiliates) that is material to assessing the objectivity of the
proxy advisor or proxy advisory service in light of the circumstances of the particular
interest, transaction, commitment, or relationship; and - Any policies and procedures used to identify, as well as the steps taken to address,
any such material conflicts of interest arising from such interest, transaction,
commitment, or relationship.
- Any information regarding an interest, transaction, commitment, or relationship of the
- (D) “Person”
- Means an individual, partnership, association, joint stock company, trust, corporation,
company, organization, other combination of individuals, government, or government entity. - (E) “Proposal”
- Means any matter that is subject to a vote of shareholders and that is included in, or has
been submitted for inclusion in, a company’s proxy statement. - (F) “Proxy advisor”
Means a person who, for compensation, provides a proxy advisory service to shareholders of
a company or to other persons with authority to vote on behalf of shareholders of a
company. It does not include:- A bank, savings and loan association or savings bank, or an affiliate thereof, that
derives less than 10% of its gross annual revenue from proxy advisory services; or - A person, including but not limited to a charitable organization exempt from federal
taxation under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, if such
person’s gross annual revenue in the last calendar or fiscal year included less than
$3 million from proxy advisory services.
- A bank, savings and loan association or savings bank, or an affiliate thereof, that
- (G) “Proxy advisory service”
Means any of the following services that are provided in connection with or in relation to
a company headquartered or incorporated in this state, or are provided to any person in
this state:- A recommendation on how to vote on a proposal, including a recommendation to abstain
from voting on a proposal; or - Development of proxy voting recommendations or policies for voting on proposals,
including establishing default recommendations or policies for voting on proposals.
- A recommendation on how to vote on a proposal, including a recommendation to abstain
- (H) “Shareholder”
- Includes a shareholder, unitholder, limited partner, or other equity owner of a company.
Section 3. Restrictions to Prevent Fraud or Deceit
(A) Any statement or material omission made in connection with offering or providing a proxy
advisory service shall be subject to
[State provision prohibiting deceptive acts and practices]
and to all other provisions of
[general citation to State UDAP law].
(B) Any statement or material omission made in connection with offering or providing a proxy
advisory service shall be subject to
[State provision prohibiting untrue statements of material fact or omissions of material fact related to securities]
and to all other provisions of
[general citation to State securities law].
Section 4. Scope
The scope of this Act includes, but is not limited to, proxy advisors registered as federal
covered investment advisers to the extent that those proxy advisors’ conduct is fraudulent or
deceptive, and to any other extent otherwise permitted by the National Securities Markets
Improvement Act of 1996.
Section 5. Severability
Section 6. Effective Date
This Act takes effect on ______. The changes in law made by this Act apply only to a proxy
advisory service provided on or after the effective date of this Act. Nothing in this law
eliminates any claim under
[general citation to State UDAP law]
or
[general citation to State securities law],
regardless of whether that claim accrues before or after the effective date of this Act.
Notes
- See 73 FR 61731 (2008); see 59 FR 38860, 38861 (1994)
- See, e.g.,
Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance - See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. §§ 77r(c), 80b-3a(b)(2) (recognizing state powers related
to fraud or deceit in connection with securities transactions and investment advice);
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 104-864, 2d Sess., at 40 (1996) (“state securities regulators to
continue to exercise their police power to prevent fraud” under the National Securities
Market Improvement Act).
Latest News >>